Grading Scale for Magazine Resale

1 N New Still in unopened original mailing envelope.
2 M Mint Only read once and stored correctly.
3 X Excellent Cover or Pages have Visible Fingerprints (Thumbing).
4 V Very Good Cover or Spine show wear or Pages are Dog-ear or Yellowed -(Sunned).
5 G Good Punch Holes or Curl-up Spine or Chipped anywhere or Cover is Creased or Loose or had Label pulled-off or Pages are Folded or High-lighted or Penciled.
6 F Fair Tear greater then an inch or Marks or Stains that bleed through anywhere or Cover in two pieces or Spine is taped or Pages are Crinkle or have Moisture Damage or any defect that would make Xeroxing difficult. Magazine is 100% readable.
7 P Poor Mildew or Cover is Partial Torn-away or Missing or Pages are Partial Rip-out or has Cutouts that don't effect text or illustrations from any article. All articles are 100% complete.
8 U Unreadable Pages are Missing or Firmly Stuck together or Brittle (Dry-rot) or have a partial Rip-out page or a Cutout or a Stain that obliterate any text or illustration from any article.

For those that have asked why not 10? I don't now of a visible physical defect that can be place between any of the above. On the other hand, I strongly believe that there are  magazines that do fall in between the above categories. For these cases, I would recommend using a decimal  point. e.g. 3.5 would be between 3 and 4. 


GRIFFIN BOOKS

Book Grading Criteria
AN As New The same perfect condition in which the book was published. There are no defects of any sort. "As New" is used very sparingly in that many books that come directly from the publisher or your local book store do not qualify as "As New"
F Fine Approaches "As New", but without having the crisp feel of a new book. May show very slightest signs of handling or use. This is our most prevalent grading. It is also the highest grading for "older books".
NF Near Fine Falls into that gray area between "fine" and "very good"
VG Very Good Some small signs of wear are apparent, but no serious defects to either the book or dust jacket. Any defects are so noted.
G Good An average used book that is structurally sound but is showing more signs of wear and use. Any defects are so noted.
F Fair A worn book that has the complete text but has some structural damage. All defects are so noted.
P Poor A book that has a completely legible text but is sufficiently worn so that its only value is that of a reader.
XL Ex-Library Library copies are always so noted no matter what the condition of the book.
BC Book Club. Book club editions are always so noted no matter what the condition of the book.

Toy Collector Association

Grade & Description
M Mint Brand new, absolutely unmarred, all original and unused.
LN Like New Free of any blemishes, nicks or scratches; original condition throughout; very little sign of use
X Excellent Minute scratches or nicks; no dents or rust
VG Very Good Few scratches, exceptionally clean, no dents or rust
G Good Scratches, small dents, dirty
F Fair Well-scratched, chipped, dented, rusted or warped condition
P Poor Beat up, junk condition, some usable parts

Birding Genealogy

Home

Railroading

Revised: 07 Mar 2003 08:04 PM